Scripto | Page Revision | Transcription

THE SUN, THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 16, 1899. CLARKE PICTURE SALE. ADDED PROOF OF ESTEEM FOR AMERICAN PAINTINGS. Those Sold Last Evening Brought Even Better Prices Than Ruled on Tuesday—$5,600 for Inness's "Wood Gatherers" the Top Figure—Bric-a-Brac Sold in Afternoon. Ninety-three more paintings out of Thomas B. Clarke's collection were sold last evening at Chickering Hall. The attendance was larger than on Tuesday evening and the buying was discriminating. The absence of dealers as any large factor in the buying is not in the least discouraging to the managers of the sale or to Mr. Clarke, who rather welcomes the somewhat diversified appreciation shown of his judgment as a collector of American artists' work. Although the total of last evening's sales was somewhat less than that of the first night's. while the number of pictures offered was the same, the sale was regarded as even a better one than Tuesday's, taken as a whole, inasmuch as the number of small and unimportant paintings in the night's catalogue was greater than in Tuesday's. These smaller examples brought higher prices proportionately than those of Tuesday, and the total number the selling price of which was less than Mr. Clarke had paid for them was only one-quarter of the whole lot, as against one-third of those sold on the evening before. Several of the Innesses, however, went at prices which could not be called high, and there was a general confidence expressed that a very few years would see an advance in the commercial value of all of them. The high figure for the night was fetched by an Inness, and beat Tuesday evening's high price, which was commanded by Homer Martin, by $100. It was $5,600, paid by George A. Hearn for the exquisite "Wood Gatherers." The spectators applauded when the bidding got to $5,000, but the bidders were not yet finished. The total for the evening was $50,555, which, with the $54,040 of the first night's sale, makes $104,595 for the paintings so far sold, or half, in number, of the whole collection. The sale of Mr. Clarke's objects of art was begun yesterday afternoon, and the $12,568.50 realized from that makes the proceeds of the entire sale to date $117,163.50. The afternoon sale presented some interesting features which will be referred to below. "The whole country has been down on Spain and things Spanish," was the facetious remark made by one spectator at its close, "but certainly those Moorish potters who in the sixteenth century took their art into Spain were vindicated today." The remark was elicited by the fact that little more than half a hundred of the Hispano-Mauresqua plaques sold for $9,082.50, the figures for the individual sales running from $200 or $300 to $1,200. The afternoon sales, like those of the evenings, are likely to grow rather than lose in interest. This afternoon the Chinese porcelains are among the pieces to be put up. The two paintings that most worked up the bidders last evening, aside from the "Wood Gatherers," were Winslow Homer's strong "The Life Line," and the same artist's splendid marine, "Maine Coast." The paintings sold at within $100 of each other. The "Maine Coast" came the earlier in the catalogue, with its fine surf bursting in the air high above the rocks, and the foaming waters bubbling between the boulders lower down, and the billows of the open ocean rolling beyond. The spectators applauded when the bidding, which had started at $1,500, jumped from $3,300 to $3,500, and again when it passed the $4,000 mark. The painting went to F. A. Bell at $4,400. "The Life Line" was the last number on the catalogue. A thousand dollars was the opening bid for it. It is the picture formerly in the Catherine Lorillard Wolfe collection. It is said that that owner paid $3,000 for it. It did not take long for the bids last evening to get above that figure, and it looked for a time as though the New York public would have the painting here for its delectation hereafter. The Metropolitan Museum of Art permitted the painting to go to Pennsylvania, perhaps for $50. Thomas E. Kirby, the auctioneer, when the bid reached $4,500, cried it for a long time and held his gavel poised, reluctant to close at that figure. The advances had all been by $100 or more. Finally he said: "I'll take $50 from you." But the New Yorkers were mum, and George W. Elkins of Philadelphia took the painting. The ten Innesses sold last evening are to be pretty well scattered. C. J. Blair of Chicago got "A Sunny Autumn Day" for $4,100. E. McMillan pair $1,400 for "The Mill Pond," and had some lively competition. Laflin Kellogg got "Autumn Silence" for $1,325. For the "End of the Rain" $500 and $600 offers were scorned, and the first bid called was $1,000. The painting went to Louis Marshall for $1,550. J. S. Bache took the "Rocky Dell" at $550. Robert Blum (whose "Toledo Water Carrier" sold last night for $290) go the "Afternoon Glow, Pompton, N. J.," for $1,650. G. W. Curtis got "Night" for $710. The buyers of some of the lesser ones were not announced. The people in the hall expressed their gratification at the announcement that Charles H. Davis's "The Deepening Shadows" and Charles Melville Dewey's "Edge of the Forest" were to go to the Corcoran gallery at Washington. The sale of the first catalogue division of Mr. Clarke's art objects, both those of large value and those of interest mainly curious, or having the interest of oddities, at the American Art Galleries in the afternoon, showed some surprises. That this sale, no less than the sale of the paintings collected by him, had attracted a good deal of attention was evidenced bu the considerable number of people drawn to the largest of the galleries in Madison Square, where the auction took place, as well as by the numerous orders sent in both by telegraph and telephone even after the sale had begun. It was evident that the conditions of travel had kept away persons who desired an opportunity to bid on some of Mr. Clarke's selections. The sale also gave indications of the change of public taste, the bids on some of the numbers going well beyond the prices paid for them by Mr. Clarke, while on articles of a wholly different class they fell so far short as to cause some remark. The classes showing the most noticeable diversities were the Hispano-Mauresque porcelains and the Persian objects. The former presented some remarkable advances on previous prices, and the latter all but went begging. Some commercial houses, however, will reap profits by no means meager on purchases of the Persian goods. There has been no sale of what is, in common parlance, called bric-à-brac within the last few years with which the best of Mr. Clarke's objects of art, sold at auction, may be compared, except that of the collection made by Charles A. Dana. Although in its entirety that collection stood by itself, there were in it specimens which present a comparative for some of Mr. Clarke's. And Mr. Dana's collection is represented in the Clarke sale by some purchases made when it was out up at auction. At yesterday's sale of No. 51 on the Clarke catalogue, a large Hispano-Mauresque plaque of brilliant copper lustre, which Mr. Clarke bought for little more than $300 at the Dana sale, sold for $650. Another plaque of this class which is declared to be among the most perfect plaques in this country, although no stress was laid upon its merits or excellence yesterday, No. 55 of the catalogue, sold at $1,200, which figure it reached from the start of $365. It was bought by W. R. Hearst. Another private buyer, who shrank behind a pseudonym, paid $510 for one of these plaques in copper and blue, with brilliant lustre, No. 21 of the catalogue. The exquisite specimens of this particular decoration, which were fairly numerous in the offerings of the afternoon, were very attractive to the buyers and bought from $200 to above $400 each. The names of the dealers were frequent among the buyers, among whom were numbered Henry Sampson, D. G. Kelekran, Stanley and Nardus, and George A. Hearn, "Richman," Greenshields, W. R. Hearst, Mrs. Wood, Mrs. Williams, Cox, Mrs. Sherwood, Mr. Einstein, Benjamin Knower, John Crosby Brown, who purchsased a Shiraz drum, it was understood, for the Metropolitan Museum; Pierre Lorillard and Mrs. Ickelheimer. Among some of the minor interesting purchases in the Persian and Indian catalogue was a fourteenth century mosaic faience tile, in turquoise, yellow, green, brown and blue, 5 1/2 x 6 1/2 inches, which was picked up by a watchful dealer at $23, and a most attractive little Persian money box, 3 1/2 inches high, of the seventeenth century, with a setting of turquoise and engraved, which George A. Hearn got at what appeared to be the bargain price of $4. A fifteenth century copper plate of mosaic design went at $2, and an Arabian carved rosewood and ivory back-scratcher at the same figure. Mr. Lorillard's purchase of a seventeenth century long dagger with a white jade handle at $20 was said to be made at less than the value of the jade alone. Some old Persian book covers, too, were sold at very low prices. The paintings selling at $400 and above are as follows, with the purchaser's name where announced: 103. H. Bolton Jones's "Sandy Shore;" W. M. Laffan..... $400 109. J. Francis Murphy's "A Sunny Morning" 450 111. Inness's "Night;" G. W. Curtis..... 710 117. D. W. Tryon's "Starlight;" G. L. Jewett 400 118. A. H. Wyant's "Twilight"..... 425 123. Winslow Homer's "The Bright Side;" S. P. Avery, Jr...... 525 136. Charles Sprague Pearce's "Meditation;" Metropolitan Museum of Art..... 510 138. D. W. Tryon's "November;" A. C. Bedford..... 950 149. Winslow Homer's "Rations;" E. H. Bernheimer..... 500 150. Inness's "Afternoon Glow, Pompton, N. J.;" Robert Blum..... 1,650 154. Charles C. Curran's "Breezy Day;" Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Arts..... 625 155. Inness's "Rocky Dell;" J. S. Bache..... 550 157. William A. Coffin's "Sunrise in January"..... 550 160. Inness's "End of the Rain;" Louis Marshall..... $1,550 165. Inness's "Autumn Silence;" Laflin Kellogg..... 1,325 168. Winslow Homer's "Maine Coast;" F. A. Bell..... 4,400 169. Inness's "Wood Gatherers;" George A. Hearn..... 5,600 172. F. D. Millet's "Lacing Her Sandal;" E. Weston..... 900 179. D. W. Tryon's "A Dewy Night—Moonrise;" James Quinian..... 1,000 180. H. Siddons Mowbray's "Evening Breeze;" W. M. Laftan..... 810 181. Charles H. Davis's "The Evening Shadows;" Corcoran Art Gallery, Washington..... 1,100 182. J. G. Brown's "A Merry Air and a Sad Heart"..... 850

183. Charles Melville Dewey's "Edge of the Forest;"Corcoran Art Gallery..... 1,050 184. Inness's "A Sunny Autumn Day;" C. T. Blair of Chicago..... 4,100 185. A. H. Wyant's "Early Morning;" E. McMillan..... 1,800 186. Winslow Homer's "The Life Line;" George W. Elkins of Philadelphia..... 4,500

THE SUN, FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 17, 1899. CLARKE PICTURE SALE. INNESS'S FAMOUS "GRAY LOWERY DAY" GOES FOR $10,150. Remarkable Price for a Picture That Was Painted in One Day—The "Clouded Sun," Another of Inness's Masterpieces, Brings $6,100—Total for the Night, $61,220.

The weather did not keep away from Chickering Hall last night the people who had evidently already made up their minds to be on hand at the sale of the third section of Mr. Thomas B. Clarke's paintings and to bid freely on them, and in some cases liberally, almost enthusiastically. A price was made for an Inness which will please the lovers of that artist's work, although they may say that there are other examples worth a great deal more than the highest priced picture of last evening and of the Clarke sale so far. This was the "Gray, Lowery Day." It was No. 260 in the catalogue, and it was bid up to $10,150. A number of people had come prepared to buy this painting, and some of them had felt reasonably confident in their guesses of from $1,200 to $1,800 as the price of it. They were badly fooled, as a number of other persons expected them to be. The first bid offered was $2,000 and the price went almost immediately to $4,600. At $6,000 the spectators applauded, and again at $7,000. After the bids had reached $7,600 the first advance at less than $100 was made. The price climbed to $8,000, and on by $50 and $100 advances to $9,000, with applause at each thousand. At $10,000 the hearty applause was irrepressible, and Mr. Kirby gave the people their way for a few moments before attempting to get another bid. The price climbed to $10,150, and everybody in the house was happy. Requests for the purchaser's name were made, but Mr. Kirby was unable to get the bidder's permission to announce it. It was bought by Henry Sampson, who had among his competitors William R. Hearst and some others. Among the admirers of the painting when it was on exhibition in the American Art Galleries was the wife of a well-known broker, who is known as a purchaser of some fine paintings, and it is understood that he was represented among the bidders. This picture has already attained fame, and has been seen by a great many people. It was painted by Inness in 1877 in one day. It is said that Mr. Clarke paid $400 for it. It is a canvas 16 x 24 inches, full of foliage and verdure and water courses, with an atmosphere saturated with moisture from sky to earth.